A Study in A Study in Scarlet 3 — I’ll Show You Mine

OK, I’ve finished hacking at Conan Doyle’s masterpiece! I’ve uploaded the result, which I edited with Word’s Track Changes turned on, if you care to have a read. (Study in Scarlet Chapter 1 edited)

So, what did I actually do? More or less what I decided last time:

  • Shortened by about 200 words (roughly 10% before I started adding)
  • Made it more Watson-centric, introducing him by name earlier on, elaborating on his time slumming about London, playing up his stated desire for peace and quiet just a little
  • Streamlined the info dump at the beginning and much of the dialogue later
  • Clarified a few things that may not make as much sense to modern or American audiences (such as the reference to Watson carrying a bull pup, what “Barts” is, etc)
  • Tried to ratchet up the tension a little bit, make this Holmes fellow a little more questionable and menacing (as I suspect he might have been to more strait-laced audiences at the time)

At the same time, I kept the original flow of things intact and (except for adding contractions and otherwise smoothing some of the text) the pattern and style of the original language. One of the important things about the revising process that I’m trying to learn is how not to allow it to erase voice. It’s so easy to edit toward neutrality, and that’s something I’m trying to avoid.

Anyhow, I think I like the result. I’ll hasten to say that I don’t consider this “better” than the original. It sounds a bit more like me now but it’s still recognizably the original. Bearing in mind that it’s not intended as an improvement, what do you think — did I more or less accomplish my goals? Do those goals even make sense? I’m curious to hear what people think.

Also: did anyone else try this little exercise? Care to share the results? (I’m willing to host files)

3 thoughts on “A Study in A Study in Scarlet 3 — I’ll Show You Mine

    1. A couple of things. I’ve been getting frustrated with my editing/revision skills, but practicing on my own work has gotten into “endless polishing” territory. I went looking for revision exercises online, but without much luck.

      Uncle Jim has suggested retyping stories that you want to learn from (and in fact Arachne Jericho did just that with another Holmes story). I quickly realized, however, that I would have a horrible time just retyping, since I’ve gotten into the habit of editing as I type my handwritten pages. Rather than suppress that, I figured I’d embrace it.

      It turned out to be a useful exercise, I think. (But don’t take my word for it, try it yourself! The original chapter is linked here and it’s under 3k — a very quick read and edit)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.